Are fermented foods like kombucha actually good for you
By published
Fermented Foods: Exploring Their Potential Health Advantages
The consumption of fermented products like kefir, kimchi, sauerkraut, and kombucha has taken place for millennia, though scientific investigations into their health effects are still in nascent stages. These foods undergo fermentation, which has historically been utilized by cultures globally for food preservation. Gabriel Vinderola, a microbiology associate professor at Argentina's National University of Litora, notes the increasing variety and industrial production of fermented foods today.
Producing these goods at an industrial level offers both advantages and challenges. Despite the elimination of chemical preservatives through fermentation, researchers from King’s College London found that approximately a third of the fermented items available in UK stores contain various additives, including preservatives like sugar and salt, potentially classifying them as ultra-processed.
This begs the question: Are fermented foods genuinely beneficial for our health, or are they simply another category of ultra-processed items we should avoid? Fermentation can enhance the availability of certain nutrients, affecting how well our bodies can utilize them. Recent interest in fermented foods in Western countries arises from the evolving understanding of the impact of our gut microbiomes on overall health.
The production process involves a controlled breakdown of carbohydrates, like starch and sugar, through microorganisms like yeast and bacteria. Variants in fermentation, from the choice of microbes to environmental variables, result in a multitude of fermented products. Common examples include kimchi, kombucha, sauerkraut, tempeh, and yogurt.
According to Paul Cotter, a senior research officer at Teagasc Food Research Centre in Ireland, fermentation can create new bioactive substances such as organic acids and peptides that may influence health. Some fermented items exhibit superior nutrient profiles relative to their non-fermented versions and may also contain probiotics, which can support gut health.
Fermented foods can be classified into two categories: those that contain live bacteria and those in which the bacteria are no longer active due to the production process, as seen in certain breads and alcoholic beverages. During fermentation, microorganisms consume the sugars present in the food, triggering biochemical reactions that yield beneficial compounds including lactic acid, recognized for its anti-inflammatory properties.
Ingested live bacteria can inhabit the gut microbiota temporarily or even permanently, conferring health benefits and helping to mitigate the presence of harmful bacteria through competitive interactions. Even in the absence of live bacteria, fermented foods still produce health-promoting elements like peptides prior to microbial death.
However, not all fermented foods are devoid of concerns. For instance, despite sourdough retaining beneficial prebiotics after baking, prevalent dietary issues, such as insufficient fiber intake among many adults in the US, underscore the need for gut health improvement. Certain fermented items can help alleviate gastrointestinal discomfort by diminishing compounds that may cause issues, such as FODMAPs, which can lead to symptoms like bloating and pain.
Moreover, fermentation can reduce gluten levels in some foods, beneficial for individuals with celiac disease. Recent scientific concerns have emerged regarding how contemporary lifestyles may adversely impact immune function, resulting in less microbial diversity. Vinderola indicates that modern diets are often fiber-deficient, exacerbated by antibiotic use, stress, and poor sleep, all of which can deplete our microbial reserves.
Fermented foods could reverse this trend. As Vinderola explains, they introduce live microbes into the digestive system, potentially enhancing immune cell education on inflammation management. Low-grade inflammation poses risks through systemic distribution of inflammatory substances, linked to various chronic conditions.
Research has suggested that the consumption of products like sauerkraut may yield marked anti-inflammatory benefits. Claudia Stäubert from the University of Leipzig detailed how sauerkraut elevates lactic acid bacteria-derived metabolic products within the bloodstream, activating immune system receptors that indicate foreign entities, thereby moderating immune reactions.
Experimental studies hint at the possibility of mental health benefits linked to fermented food consumption. A recent investigation dividing participants into groups based on their fermented food intake revealed a richer microflora and higher levels of short chain fatty acids in those consuming plant-based fermented products frequently. Andres Gomez from the University of Minnesota noted notable differences in gut chemical profiles and more stable mental health ratings among these consumers.
Additional preliminary research by Gomez points towards a connection between organic fermented foods and an increase in gamma-aminobutyric acid, an inhibitory neurotransmitter associated with calmness that may counter anxiety and depressive symptoms. Similarly, animal studies indicated that introducing kombucha into the diets of mice on a high-sugar diet led to symptomatic improvements.
While studies indicate the potential of fermented foods to aid in controlling obesity, the underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. Researchers now speculate that certain nutrients within these foods could influence appetite-regulating pathways.
The quest for personalized nutrition intensifies, with scientists exploring strategies to optimize the health benefits of specific fermented foods based on individual health profiles. Cotter has identified that variations in kefir can yield different benefits, such as cholesterol management or stress alleviation, highlighting the need for consumer awareness regarding the specific strain of microbes involved in their fermented products.
Despite findings revealing nutrient inconsistencies among commercially available fermented foods, there is optimism that ongoing research can guide improvements in production to enhance health benefits. However, mass production may reduce the microbial diversity beneficial for health.
Some commercially produced fermented items, like premade kombucha, may contain excessive sugar, while unpasteurized variants carry risks of contamination. Limited research exists on definitively determining the healthiest fermented foods due to the unique microbial composition inherent to each item.
Among fermented foods, yogurt stands out as the most studied, consistently containing specific microbial strains, facilitating research consistency. In contrast, the compositions of products like kefir vary widely, complicating comparative analysis.
Given these perspectives, there is general agreement among experts advocating for the integration of more fermented foods into diets, though recommendations suggest doing so gradually. Cotter advises individuals to experiment with a range of fermented options to discern personal digestion responses, as some may take time to adjust.
Studies show lifelong exposure to fermented foods can enhance gut microbial health. Gomez noted that among research participants, a Korean individual demonstrated a more diverse gut microbiome linked to lifelong kimchi consumption compared to their US counterparts, prompting questions about the long-term advantages of early dietary incorporation.
Ultimately, incorporating fermented foods can be beneficial for most, and regular consumption is emphasized. Vinderola concludes that sustained intake is crucial for fostering a robust immune response over time.
More news
